X

Archbishop Viganò / We do not need permission to celebrate the Holy Mass of St Pius V

Pax, pax, et non erat pax.

Observations on the open letter of Dom Alcuin Reid to Leo XIV, published by Diane Montagna on 17 November 2026

Et curabant contritionem filiæ populi mei cum ignominia,

dicentes: Pax, pax; et non erat pax.

Jer 6:14

Archbishop Carlo Maria Viganò

Dom Alcuin Reid, Prior of the small Monastery of Saint Benoît in Brignoles, France, has published an open letter to Leo XIV, which Ms. Diane Montagna (here) presents as an entreaty for the restoration of liturgical peace. He asks the Pontiff to rescind Traditionis Custodes and to restore to the Church the free celebration of all the ancient rites, as Benedict XVI had done. Dom Alcuin is a serious scholar, and I would have expected more rigor from him. Since his letter contains some correct observations within an erroneous framework, it is important to distinguish one from the other.

First and foremost, one must acknowledge what is true: that the survey of the bishops, upon which Traditionis Custodes is based, does not actually say what the motu proprio claims it says; that unity is not the same as uniformity; and that the faithful who are turned away from their dioceses truly suffer. Yet precisely because these truths are self-evident, it is painful to see them pressed into the service of a plea that strips them of their substance and seeks to subordinate them to the Revolution.

Incense to the Prince

Dom Alcuin’s letter opens with a disconcerting degree of flattery. Leo is described as “a moderate, kind man, who seeks everything that is good for the Church” and who “promotes Christ and His teaching.” Note the timing: these praises were written at the very moment when Leo, aboard the plane returning from Peru, declared that Traditionis Custodes remains in force and that, for the sake of the Church’s unity, the vast majority of Catholics celebrate “the rite of Vatican II.” We must not forget that, two months ago, Leo himself approved a Note (here) that hollows out the Church’s apostolic mission and enshrines indifferentism; furthermore, following the consecrations on July 1, he imposed excommunication upon the Society of Saint Pius X. Dom Alcuin confesses that he “struggles to understand” certain actions taken toward the leaders of other religions – a polite way of describing something truly monstrous. One who preaches Our Lord Jesus Christ cannot replace Him with “universal brotherhood” – all the more so when occupying that Cathedra veritatis which ought to serve to enlighten the nations, but which the enemies of the Church are transforming into a thronum abominationis et impietatis (Exorcism of Leo XIII).

It does not seem serious for Dom Alcuin to declare himself “astonished” by those remarks regarding the “Vatican II rite.” For once, Leo has spoken the truth: the reformed liturgy is the rite of the Council, not the Roman Rite as received from our Fathers. This is confirmed by Article 1 of Traditionis Custodes itself, which declares the liturgical books of Paul VI and John Paul II to be the sole expression of the lex orandi of the Roman Rite. Anyone who is astonished clearly has not read the text that they are calling to have abrogated.

Unity, uniformity, and the Council

The central argument of the letter is that ritual diversity is legitimate, yet the example cited undermines the position of those who invoke it. The Roman Rite is the product of centuries of organic development, whereas the Novus Ordo was constructed at a drafting table by a commission between 1964 and 1969. Cardinal Ratzinger, despite having been a key figure in the conciliar revolution, viewed the prohibition of the traditional Missal as a rupture in the history of the liturgy, one with exclusively tragic consequences. Furthermore, Dom Alcuin, who has dedicated an entire volume to the organic development of the liturgy, ought to know better than anyone that the Bugnini reform fails to meet any of the criteria he himself sets forth. Cardinals Ottaviani and Bacci, for that matter, had already pointed this out long before 2021.

But there is more. To speak of “legitimate ritual diversity” is to operate on the terrain of Sacrosanctum Concilium, which, with its “legitimate variations,” paved the way for the demolition. Dom Alcuin’s letter does not challenge the Council; rather, it invokes the Council itself to claim a place for the Missal of St. Pius V, all while failing to question the malicious counterfeit of that Missal produced by Vatican II.

Asking permission

Dom Alcuin implores the Pope to “permit” the celebration of the ancient rites. But the Catholic Mass of St. Pius V requires no such permission. The Bull Quo Primum grants it in perpetuum and concludes with a sanctioning clause that cannot be violated without incurring guilt: Nulli ergo omnino hominum liceat hanc paginam Nostræ permissionis, statuti, ordinationis, mandati, præcepti, concessionis, indulti, declarationis, voluntatis, decreti et inhibitionis infringere, vel ei ausu temerario contraire. Thus, no one may violate this document or oppose it with reckless audacity, not even a subsequent Pontiff. Benedict XVI himself acknowledged that this Missal was never abrogated. If it was never abrogated, no one can prohibit it; and if someone speaks of “granting” it, they implicitly admit that it is revocable, thereby accepting the very principle that Traditionis Custodes subsequently applied.

Experience proves this to be true. The Hegelian-inspired attempt made by Benedict XVI – the thesis of the Novus Ordo, the antithesis of the Vetus Ordo, and the synthesis consisting of the coexistence of both – lasted a mere fourteen years, and a single signature sufficed to undo it. A favor can be withdrawn; a right cannot. To plead for a new favor from someone who has just declared that he will not grant it is tantamount to repeating the very action that brought us to this point.

The peace of the tombs

The title of Dom Alcuin’s letter speaks of liturgical peace. The Prophet Jeremiah has already passed judgment on those who treat the wounds of the people superficially, saying, “Peace, peace,” when there is no peace (Jer 6:14); and Our Lord warned: Nolite arbitrari quia venerim mittere pacem in terram; non veni pacem mittere, sed gladium – “Do not think that I have come to bring peace upon the earth; I have come not to bring peace, but the sword” (Mt 10:34-35). And again: Pacem relinquo vobis, pacem meam do vobis; non quomodo mundus dat, ego do vobis – “Peace I leave with you; my peace I give to you. Not as the world gives do I give to you” (Jn 14:27). The peace that Dom Alcuin proposes is that of the Ecclesia Dei compromise: the traditional Catholic Mass in exchange for silence regarding the Council. It is the peace of the world, which lasts only as long as the tolerance of those in power persists. But this is not peace; it is an armistice in which Catholics are induced to trade their acceptance of the doctrinal errors of the conciliar and synodal church for maniples, stoles, and folded chasubles. Furthermore, even when Summorum Pontificum was in force, priests who celebrated the ancient rite were often “strongly encouraged” (that is to say, coerced) to also celebrate the Montinian rite.

The open letter laments that many of the faithful, driven out of their dioceses, seek “refuge” with the Society of St. Pius X or elsewhere, and it calls for the building of “bridges.” Yet, these faithful are not fleeing because of liturgical rubrics; they are fleeing for the sake of the Faith, a Faith they can no longer find elsewhere. To frame this as a problem of “communion,” rather than as a symptom of a doctrinal crisis, is akin to treating a fever while ignoring the underlying infection. Dom Alcuin should know this well; he himself once sought “refuge” outside the Bergoglian church to be ordained a priest, only to later choose to leave that refuge in order to remain “in communion” with the very people from whom he had originally fled.

And if Dom Alcuin reproaches the bishops for their “ideology” – the notion that everything following the Council is perfect and beyond reform – he does so while addressing a Pope who shares that very ideology, as he has confirmed a thousand times over, most recently on the plane returning from Lima.

What should be requested

It is clear that Traditionis Custodes must be abrogated – assuming that it ever possessed any legal force at all, given also who drafted it. It is an unjust act, based pretextually upon a manipulated inquiry, and it strikes at the people of God in their most sacred possession. Its abrogation must be demanded as an act of justice, not as a favor; and it must be requested alongside that which constitutes the very reason for such a demand: namely, the condemnation of the errors that led to the persecution of the Catholic Mass. A Pope who were to restore the Tridentine Missal while leaving the Second Vatican Council intact would be giving with one hand and taking away with the other. The peace that the Pontiffs have taught is the peace of Christ in the kingdom of Christ – not an armistice between two irreconcilable religions and their equally irreconcilable liturgical forms.

To the faithful, I say what I have been repeating for some time: Resistite fortes in fide – Stand firm in the faith (1 P 5:9). No “rescript” can take away from you what Pius V guaranteed in perpetuity. Attend the traditional Mass, the Mass of all time, even when pastors forbid it; do so with the prudence and charity of children, and without waiting for a letter, however courteous it may be, to bring about what only Providence will grant, at the hour that pleases God. In addition, She who has defeated all heresies will watch over us during this terrible trial as well. The zealous apostle of globalism has stated that Traditionis Custodes was a decision of Pope Francis, and we shall continue to follow it.” We, as Catholics, can reply that Quo Primum was a decision of Saint Pius V, and we foir our part shall continue to follow it. Quibuslibet contrariis minime obstantibus.

+ Carlo Maria Viganò, Archbishop

18 November MMXXVI

In Dedicatione Basilicarum Ss.Apostolorum Petri et Pauli

exsurgedomine

 

Aldo Maria Valli:
Post Correlati